Students and judges may refer to this sample to help identify what will be required and judged for the symposium oral presentations.
STUDENT RESEARCH SYMPOSIUM JUDGING SHEET
| Presenter Name | Presentation/ Visual Design (1-5) |
Delivery (1-5) |
Research Question & Methods (1-5) |
Outcomes & Significance (1-5) |
Total (20 max) |
Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SCORING GUIDE
Each category scored 1-5, max total = 20.
| Category | 1-2 (needs work) |
3 (on track) |
4-5 (strong) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Presentation/Visual Design | Disorganized slides; too much or too little content; images hard to read or poorly labeled; text doesn't suit the audience | Mostly organized with clear narrative flow; images helpful; text readable by the audience. | Slides intentionally designed around a clear narrative; content load optimized; images well-contextualized; text targeted to audience. |
| Delivery | Unfamiliar with content; unrehearsed; vocabulary inappropriate for audience; struggles with questions. | Comfortable with content; well-practiced; vocabulary accessible; handles most questions. | Conveys real-life expertise; polished transitions; confident and fluent Q&A; vocabulary efficient and audience-appropriate. |
| Research Question & Methods | No clear research question or goal; methods missing, unexplained, or poorly matched to the question. | Research question clearly stated; methods outlined and shown to be appropriate for the question/goal. | Sophisticated, feasible question; innovative or theoretically informed methods, critical reasoning evident in approach selection. |
| Outcomes & Significance | Outcomes absent or unexplained; no discussion of value, impact, or next steps. | Outcomes clearly shown and appropriate to project scope; value of work and next steps explained. | Outcomes novel and fully analyzed; clear understanding of broader significance; concrete plan for future development or impact. |